The Mightiest Colors

Lexi Dever writes:

With the unveiling of the new orange (Mighty) Ducks jersey, my housemates and I were debating which color scheme worked best for Anaheim —, their current one or their original one?
To prove my point that they should be eggplant and jade, I mocked up both an orange and jade version of the same design. Then I did a black one and an eggplant one. However, my housemates and I remain divided.
So I turn to the Icethetics community: which of these four jersey color schemes is the best?